Thursday, June 30, 2005

The Ebb and Flow of "Legality" within Digital Content - MGM Vs. Grokster


I think we, as consumers, have general disdain for big business buying legal precedent that protect their archaic business models. Unfortunately, there is not much a general consumer can do to voice an opinion in the courts of law where big money is often the victor. Likewise, start-up companies, with funds nary enough to run their day to day business, cannot afford the luxury of big legal departments and slush funds with which to fend off the elderly velvet lined pockets of major industry players. The MGM Vs. Grokster ruling of recent provides these major players with the precedent they need to ward off technologies and initiatives that may challenge their deep rooted and stubborn version of distributing content. This decision has been oft-lamented by most every major technology commentary of late, and I recently ran across a little Q&A with Larry Lessig of Creative Commons, a non-prof who seeks to develop flexible copyright rules for creative content:

"Ten Years of Chilled Innovation"

I must admit, the advent of technology, and the pathways with which we are provided to distribute and share popular media content (art, music, movies, TV, etc) certainly do bring in to question the legality of certain aspects of transferring digital data, as there is little precedent by which to measure what may be considered "stealing", "sharing", "legal distribution", or whatever buzzword sought for perpetuation amongst consumers may be used. In light of the recent ruling, I must admit its hard not to become a modern day Robin Hood of digital media whereas one steals from the rich (big labels) and gives to the poor (consumers). Outside of a few initiatives supported by the big publishers, where-as media content gets parsed into small pieces and sold a-la-carte to consumers (iTunes, et al, and a few Movie distribution sites), there is still a dearth of understanding as to how copyrights should work in our digital world. Especially in an increasingly global economy; different countries are creating different rulings, and confusing the system even more so than ever before.

The current state of things is pretty sad, as it's becoming a one-sided battle where the few weapons consumers and start-ups may have are being stripped by legal decisions bought by big money and endless court cases. I'm not getting on an anti-corporate soap box here, but rather, I wish many of the big media publishers would realize that technology should be their friend, and find ways to embrace and create new business models by which everyone profits. Our digital world should enable cheaper yet much wider distribution of content, and these publishers should seek amazing ways to free their content and get it in to the hands of more people. Unfortunately, these old croons are set in their old ways of set prices for physical products, and they want the same type of physical control to extend in to a non-physical universe (digital baby!).

It's even more unfortunate that our court system in the States is bending over backwards to oblige the money being shoved in their faces (not to say they are accepting bribes). There is the blatant skewing of stats and figures by big industry lawyers and statisticians that show how much digital "piracy" is ruining their financial futures (it's even funnier that pirates are being romanticized by the same industry through several recent movie endeavors). I would equate this to a manufacturer of horse drawn carriages complaining that automobiles are illegal because they hurt their financial future stole the wheel as a transportation device (it's not perfect, but you get the ridiculousness of the concept here). I'll save my commentary on RIAA and MPAA suing actual consumers for another day (see: RIAA Sues 784 More!), but I simply wonder how long these players can go on treating consumers as criminals before it snaps back in their faces.

"Increasingly, this court is oblivious to the costs of its own decisions. The Reagan Administration pushed the regulatory-impact statements. I think we need an equivalent Ronald Reagan to push the judicial-opinion-impact statement that tries to calculate the efficiency costs of certain legal rules. I continue to be disappointed in Justice Souter's obtuseness to the costs of the complexity that he adds to the copyright system."


For certain, if every innovative idea will have to be stacked up against a legality ruler and have measures in place to prevent copyright infringement, it will no doubt deter most from actually pursuing applications of content distribution and sharing. Considering the cloud that hangs over the copyright system will only grow denser the more court cases pile on top of it, assures that less people will attempt to tackle the enforcement of increasingly nebulous and complicated rules.

"Take the number of [Apple (AAPL )] iPods sold and take the number of iTunes songs sold, and divide it, and it's something like 25 songs per iPod. You know there's more than 25 songs on every iPod. Where did people get their music? Well, they rip it from their CDs. Is that legal? Good question. It's not protected by the audio home recording act, which explicitly said you're allowed to make an analog copy of your CD. But [on the iPod], it's a digital copy.

Ask [former Motion Picture Association of America CEO] Jack Valenti or ask the recording industry whether it's fair use to be copying CDs. Well, they don't think it's fair use. So in selling iPods...[Apple is] encouraging CDs to be ripped. If it weren't Apple, which is a relatively strong company, but another company that's starting with this new technology, what would happen if you filed a lawsuit against them? Your lawyer would tell you, you can't afford to fight this."


Organizations like RIAA and the MPAA would love to create an evolving copyright system that they can control, shifting and changing the wording and application of it to meet their ever tightening fist of control on the marketplace. I am really disturbed at their ability to create an aura of right and wrong with regards to creative content, something that they define in an ever mercurial way. I believe that even when you purchase a song from the Itunes Music Store, the copyright agreement states that it can be changed at any time. The music you buy today, may not work for you in the future, because let's say they start charging a price per time the music is listened to, and you've gone over the limit! It may sound silly, but this evolving concept of content control is not really that far-fetched. If this happened, finding a way to circumvent the play limit on the song you "purchased" would be considered "criminal" activity, and thus, in a moral culture, you would be considered wrong, perhaps even sinful(?)! Ridiculous, scary, and possible at the same time. "Stealing" songs could keep you out of eternal joy in heaven people!

I have no idea where the proper balance is with this. The fair and profitable application of copyrights to digital content is a difficult thing to define and enforce. What I do know is that the industry who produce and publish the content should be at the forefront of this creative thinking. Instead, the distribution and sharing models have been relegated to pioneers who are being pushed to the "underworld" of computing. Decisions like this continue to alienate customers, stifle innovative ideas, and increase a media conglomerates' cold grip on a marketplace where consumers are supposed to hold the reigns of control in a competitive economy.

16 Comments:

At 2:24 AM, Blogger haroldgonzo8647 said...

='Brand New News Fr0m The Timber Industry!!'=

========Latest Profile==========
Energy & Asset Technology, Inc. (EGTY)
Current Price $0.15
================================

Recognize this undiscovered gem which is poised to jump!!

Please read the following Announcement in its Entierty and
Consider the Possibilities�
Watch this One to Trad,e!

Because, EGTY has secured the global rights to market
genetically enhanced fast growing, hard-wood trees!

EGTY trading volume is beginning to surge with landslide Announcement.
The value of this Stoc,k appears poised for growth! This one will not
remain on the ground floor for long.

KEEP READING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

===============
"BREAKING NEWS"
===============

-Energy and Asset Technology, Inc. (EGTY) owns a global license to market
the genetically enhanced Global Cedar growth trees, with plans to
REVOLUTIONIZE the forest-timber industry.

These newly enhanced Globa| Cedar trees require only 9-12 years of growth
before they can be harvested for lumber, whereas worldwide growth time for
lumber is 30-50 years.

Other than growing at an astonishing rate, the Global Cedar has a number
of other benefits. Its natural elements make it resistant to termites, and
the lack of oils and sap found in the wood make it resistant to forest fire,
ensuring higher returns on investments.
T
he wood is very lightweight and strong, lighter than Poplar and over twice
as strong as Balsa, which makes it great for construction. It also has
the unique ability to regrow itself from the stump, minimizing the land and
time to replant and develop new root systems.

Based on current resources and agreements, EGTY projects revenues of $140
Million with an approximate profit margin of 40% for each 9-year cycle. With
anticipated growth, EGTY is expected to challenge Deltic Timber Corp. during
its initial 9-year cycle.

Deltic Timber Corp. currently trades at over $38.00 a share with about $153
Million in revenues. As the reputation and demand for the Global Cedar tree
continues to grow around the world EGTY believes additional multi-million
dollar agreements will be forthcoming. The Global Cedar nursery has produced
about 100,000 infant plants and is developing a production growth target of
250,000 infant plants per month.

Energy and Asset Technology is currently in negotiations with land and business
owners in New Zealand, Greece and Malaysia regarding the purchase of their popular
and profitable fast growing infant tree plants. Inquiries from the governments of
Brazil and Ecuador are also being evaluated.

Conclusion:

The examples above show the Awesome, Earning Potential of little
known Companies That Explode onto Investor�s Radar Screens.
This s-t0ck will not be a Secret for long. Then You May Feel the Desire to Act Right
Now! And Please Watch This One Trade!!


GO EGTY!


All statements made are our express opinion only and should be treated as such.
We may own, take position and sell any securities mentioned at any time. Any
statements that express or involve discussions with respect to predictions,
goals, expectations, beliefs, plans, projections, object'ives, assumptions or
future events or perfo'rmance are not
statements of historical fact and may be
"forward,|ooking statements." forward,|ooking statements are based on expectations,
estimates and projections at the time the statements are made that involve a number
of risks and uncertainties which could cause actual results or events to differ
materially from those presently anticipated. This newsletter was paid $3,000 from
third party (IR Marketing). Forward,|ooking statements in this action may be identified
through the use of words such as: "pr0jects", "f0resee", "expects". in compliance with
Se'ction 17. {b), we disclose the holding of EGTY shares prior to the publication of
this report. Be aware of an inherent conflict of interest resulting from such holdings
due to our intent to profit from the liquidation of these shares. Shar,es may be sold
at any time, even after positive statements have been made regarding the above company.
Since we own shares, there is an inherent conflict of interest in our statements and
opinions. Readers of this publication are cautioned not
to place undue reliance on
forward,|ooking statements, which are based on certain assumptions and expectations
involving various risks and uncertainties that could cause results to differ materially
from those set forth in the forward- looking statements. This is not solicitation to
buy or sell st-0cks, this text is or informational purpose only and you should seek
professional advice from registered financial advisor before you do anything related
with buying or selling st0ck-s, penny st'0cks are very high risk and you can lose your
entire inves,tment.

 
At 10:58 PM, Blogger ayanna48maribel said...

Just passing by your blog and though you'd like this website.

 
At 11:21 AM, Blogger Joe Muka said...

Hi, Saw your site late night. Some of your ideas I may use for my site about info voip It's kind of a boring topic...I liked some of your info.

 
At 7:27 PM, Blogger PolarTrader said...

Hi!

I really enjoy your blog aimed at VoiP Solution.
This VoiP Soulution is based on P2P and I'am very impressed of all the options. It must be some of the best Voip Solutions Architecture on the net.
As an Affiliate you get a very lucrative income potentials, Total company payout: 90%
cheapest solution voip
and
cheapest solution voip

Regards

Trond K.

 
At 7:18 PM, Blogger PolarTrader said...

Hi! Your Blog about Voip and Web Conference is great. I have a Website with a great Web Conference Software. There also is a Trial for only one dollar month. free video conference software

Take a look when you have time!

Trond

 
At 1:19 AM, Blogger Gordon said...

Hello, your blog is informative . I have a website related tofx chart, so you can compare the currency rates of different time frames easily. Charts of major currency pairs can be found there, the site should be helpful to your forex trading.

 
At 12:35 PM, Blogger JT said...

Great Blog! A real pleasure to read! Do you know that Traffic Portals will really boost your conversion rates and generate exclusively yours leads? We offer VOIP webinars - Marketing Courses Using Web Conferences about Traffic Portals I also have a website that talks about various high profile topics such as Retirement and includes an eBusiness Directory. I also would like to tell all of you reading this terrific blog about Retirement that should you be in need of a terrific host for a serious eCommerce Website that www.Kiosk.ws is Awesome Hosting value! They have the best online support team for all of your technical questions and a 3 minute emergency pager too. Looking to start your own affiliate program? They have an excellent script for you! They give you $70,000 dollars worth of software to build just about any type of e-commerce website you need! Go check it out if you get a chance. You can make more money than you spend and Create Free Will for Yourself! Again, Great Blog! Thanks. The info on Retirement Sooner was very informative!

 
At 7:09 PM, Blogger CTMunkii said...

Hello Eric P, I bet when you started a The Ebb and Flow of blog, you didn't think you would get some random person like me, who getting bored trying to find skateboard apparel has decided to communicate with the wider world! I dunno, maybe you did, anyway as you can tell I am going stir crazy, so I'd better not write anymore nonsense on what I think is a good looking blog! Anyway, nice to contribute, and I am off into the great unknown search for more skateboard apparel. It's good to talk!

 
At 3:33 PM, Blogger CTMunkii said...

Hi Eric P, I thought I would post on your The Ebb and Flow of thread as I was here. Actually I am trying to find skateboard t shirts blogs, and getting bored looking and thought I would post cos I like your blog. I hope you dont mind. OK, now I've done that I'd better go looking for more skateboard t shirts. Cool blog Eric P!

 
At 3:13 PM, Blogger A. Weinberger said...

Hi, Thanks for your interesting blog. Keep up the great work! I also have a site & blog about service voip, please feel free to visit.

 
At 6:37 PM, Blogger Johnny said...

Just visited your blog, It is interesting to read. If you need some free cell phone tips, please click here .

 
At 7:39 AM, Blogger telekom said...

Hi,

We may share some interest part of telecommunications story or update, so visit my website **Telecom** site/blog. It pretty much covers Telecommunications Updates related stuff.

Have a nice day.
Otai

 
At 5:53 AM, Blogger mwcart said...

Great blog you have. Just wanted to let you know that I've found a great place for Reward Card">Reward Card & Best Travel Reward Credit Card
. Keep up the great blog. Best wishes.

 
At 3:08 AM, Blogger VoIp Solutions said...

Hi, Thanks for your interesting blog. Keep up the great work! I also have a site & blog about flyfone voip, please feel free to visit.

 
At 10:22 PM, Blogger moriswarner7096 said...

I read over your blog, and i found it inquisitive, you may find My Blog interesting. So please Click Here To Read My Blog

http://pennystockinvestment.blogspot.com

 
At 6:05 AM, Blogger eddyjones3611423262 said...

Get any Desired College Degree, In less then 2 weeks.

Call this number now 24 hours a day 7 days a week (413) 208-3069

Get these Degrees NOW!!!

"BA", "BSc", "MA", "MSc", "MBA", "PHD",

Get everything within 2 weeks.
100% verifiable, this is a real deal

Act now you owe it to your future.

(413) 208-3069 call now 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home